After his rival stole the woman of his dreams, Trevor O'Quinn decides to focus his efforts on his studies. Final year Vocal Performance at Trinity College in Dublin is stressful enough, but when a chance meeting flares the feelings never quite quenched, Trevor realizes Cassie Doyle is still the woman he loves. But her dream has turned into a nightmare. Cassandra Doyle always cared for Trevor, ever since they connected over having American mothers. So when a masked stranger sweeps her off her feet at the Christmas Masquerade, she hopes it's him. But when Robbie McConaghy claims to be the man she fell in love with, she resigns herself to the fact Trevor would never be more than a friend. When Trevor, Cassie, and Robbie are cast in the musical drama department's production of the Phantom of the Opera as the three leads, Cassie comes face to face with a difficult choice, one that will affect all their futures. Trevor loves singing and to be cast in the title role of the production is the pinnacle of his college career. However, with Cassie's choice looming before them, Trevor knows they are approaching the point of no return and in Dublin fair city, their lives will change forever. **Though this can be read as a standalone, for the best reading experience, please consider reading Across the Irish Sea first!