New York City is a city of immigrants. It is founded on the principle that through commerce and dedication anyone can become successful enough for their subsequent generations to thrive. Three ENL classes at Morris Academy for Collaborative Studies have explored and debated the validity of this sentiment during their academic year. This book is the product of that exploration and debate. Through their writing on language, migration, and social activism one can see the nuances, conflict, and emotion that comes with the idea of a shining city on a hill